The Delusional Messiah's Bicycle
"Bicycling to War" by Richard Cohen (washingtonpost.com):
"Old joke: A man repeatedly rides a bike across the Mexican-U.S. border. Each time, he's stopped by Customs and the bike is taken apart. Nothing is found. Finally, one day a Customs official offers the man immunity from prosecution if only he will tell what he's smuggling. The man pauses for a second, shrugs and says, "Bicycles."
I offer you this because I have just finished Bob Woodward's compelling new book, "Plan of Attack," and while it contains several gasps per chapter -- more reasons why George Tenet should be fired, more proof that Condi Rice is in over her head and more reasons that Dick Cheney should be medicated -- the stunning disclosure that I expected is simply not there. I thought Woodward would reveal the real reason George Bush went to war in Iraq. It turns out we already knew.
The "bicycle" in this case has been in plain sight: Bush's conviction that he is a servant of God and history, chosen to liberate Iraq, bring democracy to the Middle East and make sure the United States is safe from terrorism. In the two lengthy on-the-record interviews the president granted Woodward, he makes it abundantly clear that, somehow, this is all one package in his mind -- even though to others, Saddam Hussein posed no danger to America at all. Among other things, he had no links to al Qaeda and apparently had no weapons of mass destruction.
For a while, though, Bush was entitled to think otherwise about the weapons, because, among other reasons, the CIA director had assured him of their existence. "It's a slam dunk case!" Tenet told the president -- and then, for emphasis, repeated his assurance: "Don't worry, it's a slam dunk!" For Bush, who surprisingly had some doubts about Iraq's WMD capabilities, Tenet's firmness was impressive. "That was very important," Woodward quotes him as saying.
But as Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz told Vanity Fair in an amazingly candid interview, Hussein's purported arsenal was almost beside the point -- not the prime reason for going to war. The real reason, as Woodward's book makes clear, was the president's conviction that he was in an epochal fight against evil and had the historic opportunity to reorder the Middle East.
I confess that I have both known this and not known this. It has been apparent for some time but a little hard to comprehend. Possibly, I and others thought, there was another reason -- like evening the score for Saddam Hussein's attempt to kill Bush's father or to finish the Persian Gulf War, which had ended unsatisfactorily. After all, the intent to go to war had seemed to arise out of nowhere -- a mere 72 days after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. Where had it come from?
My guess is Cheney. The Bush-Cheney relationship remains as sealed as the one between Bush and his wife. Woodward seems to have been a fly on the White House wall, but we learn little about what Bush and Cheney discussed when they were not in formal meetings. We do know, though, that Colin Powell considered Cheney obsessed with Iraq and so determined to make the case for war that the vice president exaggerated the threat and in some cases -- this is me talking now -- just plain lied.
Whatever the case, the real news in this engrossing book is not exactly what Bush says but that he says it at all -- and sometimes, surprisingly, both articulately and with some erudition. Here is a man convinced that he did the right thing, convinced -- despite contrary evidence -- that there was some sort of link between Saddam Hussein and terrorism and that, as he told Mexican President Vicente Fox, "The security of the United States is on the line."
This is what Bush said on the eve of the war and what, presumably, he still believes. When Woodward asked him last December what his reaction had been to Powell's private warning that things could go bad in postwar Iraq, Bush said, "And my reaction to that is, is that my job is to secure America. And that I also believe that freedom is something people long for. And that if given the chance, the Iraqis over time would seize the moment. My frame of mind is focused on what I told you -- the solemn duty to protect America."
Those, though, were not the aims Powell had questioned. Rather, he had talked about the difficulties of implementing them in an ethnically fractured land where democracy was historically unknown. Bush simply ignored all of that, because essentially he believed what he believed. "I sat there somewhat nonplussed," Woodward wrote.
He had uncovered the bicycle."
(apologies to Richard Cohen and the Post for re-publishing this verbatim, but it just says EXACTLY what is wrong with Bush).
Pages
Blog Archive
-
▼
2004
(1728)
-
▼
April
(120)
- Anti-war Is Not Anti-American Ronald Reagan's for...
- Are We Allowed To Ask "Why Not?" Reuters reports ...
- Olympic Embarrasment For Bush Former Olympic Cham...
- Top Italian TV news reader quits: "A leading tel...
- Stunted development: "The president of the World...
- Was the North Korean Blast an Assasination Attempt...
- What Would Maggie Say? Margaret "the lady's not f...
- People of the USA, Your Society Is Sick Secret Se...
- True Colours Come Shining Through... Iraqis Say C...
- Howard's Gamble For several months, Australian po...
- Religious Nut-cases Rule The World OK? Once again...
- The High Price Of Pacifism The Guardian reports o...
- Is Rice Bush's "Second Wife"?: "There is a buzz ...
- Washington's chosen ones face the axe: "The UN e...
- Does God Vote Republican? "The administration is ...
- Outrage! "Israeli authorities are investigating...
- Picking New Puppet Masters So what do you do when...
- Why Idealists Support the UN The UN was originall...
- New assault on porn could prove embarrassing for s...
- Pakistan 'ends al-Qaeda search': "The Pakistani ...
- UN is ready to go... As soon as the USA agrees to ...
- It's now obvious to most rational people that the ...
- Australia started the war before it started Bob W...
- US Needs To Go Back To The UN... And Apologise Ev...
- California votes against Diebold: "California el...
- USA's Disappearing Freedoms A 50-year-old civilia...
- Slate explains that Bush never decided to go to wa...
- A recently established, right-wing Christian colle...
- With God on His Side...: "As a self-described 'm...
- General: Much of Iraq's Forces Have Quit: "About...
- How To "Find" WMDs In Iraq Islam Online reports t...
- Rumsfeld's Smoking Gun? Another bombshell from Bo...
- Negroponte is Bush Neo-con Cabal Insider Fascist T...
- Bush gets the Monty Python treatment from former P...
- The Delusional Messiah's Bicycle "Bicycling to Wa...
- A leaked memo from a member of Iraq's Coalition Pr...
- Why Has It Taken The US Media ONE YEAR to Publish ...
- So much for the "partnership of equals"... Bob Wo...
- Thanks For The Memories, Saddam If you have some ...
- These Thieving Fools Are Supposed to Take Control ...
- Connect the Dots... Is Ariel Sharon the man at th...
- Bremer Has Had Enough Bush has been insisting tha...
- Who Would Do Such A Thing? Special agent Francisc...
- Another Cunning Bush Plan... Facing a chronic sho...
- Even the The New York Times is getting serious in ...
- Truth Rings Out! Robert Fisk angrily declares tha...
- George W. Bush on the Middle East Road Map: "I'm ...
- Congratulations to Tom Tomorrow for highlighting t...
- Paul Bremer says US-trained Iraqi forces are not r...
- Lack of critical media gave Government free rein o...
- Guantanamo Cases FINALLY Reach Supreme Court The ...
- A new leaflet is being widely distributed in Bagh...
- What's The Real Problem? Another day, another pai...
- Can US Voters Handle The Truth??? The White House...
- Get Out Now, Before We Are Thrown Out - by John Pi...
- Guardian: Dangerous liaisons "Washington insiders...
- Post-9/11 Responsibility and Accountability As th...
- The Arabs Were Right: It's A Crusade A new book, ...
- AlterNet takes a good look at Bush's attempts to u...
- President Bush Needs Your Help - Click here to vot...
- Editor and Publisher has the complete text of Bus...
- Baghdad Airport Is Now A US Dometic Flight Michae...
- Going Round The Bend Riverbend, a girl blogger fr...
- The Australian reports that "an Iraqi has died of...
- Bush Holds Press Conference, Says Nothing It was ...
- WorkingForChange: Abu Musad al Zarqawi has two leg...
- An interesting article from the Toronto Sun : "A...
- Ashcroft's Turn To Feel The Heat FBI Director Tho...
- Gareth Smith - Anti-War Hero!!! Gareth Smith, a 6...
- Lessons Of History A Report on Mesopotamia - by T...
- One of Condoleeza Rice's former University profess...
- Is Bush An Idiot? How else do you describe his in...
- Gitmo Disgrace "A human rights conference in Yeme...
- Future Wars "The Rise of the Machines is at the h...
- WorkingForChange Quote of the Day: Senator Ted Ke...
- Aunty, Come Back... One of the great unsung trage...
- Phantom Flight From Florida: From The Tampa Tribun...
- What the Hell are Untermenschen? The Americans ha...
- What The Hell Is A "Warning?" The newly declassif...
- What the Hell is "Sovereignty"? "Contrary to US a...
- Nobody Believes Condi Any More, Not Even the FBI: ...
- Language Barriers Condi Rice, asked about a memo ...
- How Did We Get Into This Mess? George Bush: The U...
- Too Many Innocent People Are Dying: "A spokesman...
- Condi Decides to Keep Lying
- Gandhi: Let's Declare War on Stupidity The relea...
- The war on terror misfired. Blame it all on the ne...
- A War President's Job: "Since Sept. 11, 2001, Am...
- Deeper into the abyss: "US efforts are certain t...
- Shock! Murdoch Paper Reveals: Murdoch Supports Bus...
- Smokescreen? Provocation? Or Both? So why DID the...
- UPI says that by confronting al-Sadr now, Bremer a...
- Bush Versus al-Sadr: Bush: 'This is one person w...
- The Guardian dares to publish a Naomi Klein report...
- How To Get Out Of Iraq: A Non-Violent Exit Strateg...
- "A nightmare of nationwide chaos... " It's one t...
- The Beginning Of The End? What will happen if Shi...
- Shiite Clashes in with Coalition in Najaf Baghdad:...
- Buy Now: "Worse Than Watergate: The Secret Preside...
- TOMPAINE.com - Worse Than Watergate?: "President...
-
▼
April
(120)