Susan Sontag on the Abu Ghraib images:
"For a long time - at least six decades - photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts are judged and remembered. The memory museum is now mostly a visual one. Photographs have an insuperable power to determine what people recall of events, and it now seems likely that the defining association of people everywhere with the rotten war that the Americans launched preemptively in Iraq last year will be photographs of the torture of Iraqi prisoners in the most infamous of Saddam Hussein's prisons, Abu Ghraib.
The slogans and phrases fielded by the Bush administration and its defenders have been chiefly aimed at limiting a public relations disaster - the dissemination of the photographs - rather than dealing with the complex crimes of leadership, policies and authority revealed by the pictures. There was, first of all, the displacement of the reality on to the photographs themselves. The administration's initial response was to say that the president was shocked and disgusted by the photographs - as if the fault or horror lay in the images, not in what they depict. There was also the avoidance of the word torture. The prisoners had possibly been the objects of 'abuse', eventually of 'humiliation' - that was the most to be admitted. 'My impression is that what has been charged thus far is abuse, which I believe technically is different from torture,' secretary of defence Donald Rumsfeld said at a press conference. 'And therefore I'm not going to address the torture word.' Words alter, words add, words subtract. It was the strenuous avoidance of the word 'genocide' while the genocide of the Tutsis in Rwanda was being carried out 10 years ago that meant the American government had no intention of doing anything. To call what took place in Abu Ghraib - and, almost certainly, in other prisons in Iraq and in Afghanistan, and in Guantanamo - by its true name, torture, would likely entail a public investigation, trials, court martials, dishonourable discharges, resignation of senior military figures and responsible cabinet officials, and substantial reparations to the victims. Such a response to our misrule in Iraq would contradict everything this administration has invited the American public to believe about the virtue of American intentions and America's right to unilateral action on the world stage in defence of its interests and its security. .."
May 24, 2004
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Pages
Blog Archive
-
▼
2004
(1728)
-
▼
May
(146)
- Abu Ghraib Shame Prompts 20 Death Certificates in ...
- CHENEY, FEITH, WOLFOWITZ, RUMSFELD MUST ALL RESIGN...
- ABC News Poll: "Come on folks. 50 percent of Bu...
- Hey Kids! Time to play a new reality simulation g...
- Puppets Grab Their Strings Well, another big surp...
- 10 U-turns "The appointment of Mr Allawi is the c...
- Hill stops officer from appearing at Iraqi abuse h...
- Another bullseye from Ted Rall:
- Scant Evidence Cited in Long Detention of Iraqis: ...
- The Independent says that Allawi "is the person th...
- "Practically ignored in the Abu Ghraib torture sca...
- How To Become The Leader Of Iraq DJ Iraq Council ...
- USA Gets Their Man? Iraq's new prime minister-to-...
- Miramax founders to distribute 'Fahrenheit 9/11'.:...
- Conspiracy theorists are asking "Who killed Nick ...
- Hypocrite Of The Week Perle Criticizes the U.S. w...
- Globalization per se is not enough to help the poo...
- CIA Was Using Torture Long Before Abu Ghraib: "N...
- Warlike US Battles Utopian Urges: "The United St...
- We Demand Accountability The Australian governmen...
- What do you do when you've released a new, honey-p...
- Rafah zoo levelled in Israel raid: "Among the ca...
- Australian knew of prison abuse : "An Australian...
- Step One: Admit You Have A Problem... Bravo to Th...
- The Covert Kingdom:: "Forget about changing thei...
- Michael Berg Demands Justice For Beheaded Son Let...
- Food For Thought "Over sixty years ago the leader...
- Bush, Blair and Howard: The honeymoon is over... n...
- An Ex-Marine Speaks Out On The Horror of Iraq STA...
- President Nader? Consider this scenario: a little...
- Your bill for the war: "Amount you owe for the w...
- Bush Boyz Plundering Iraqi Oil? Muzhir al-Dulaymi...
- Light Relief Q: How many members of the Bush Admi...
- The World Versus Bush Gotta love how crises of in...
- Here's your war on terrorism, here's the progress ...
- A Poisoned Chalice The new US resolution before t...
- World Rejects Smirking Chimp Morality In spite of...
- CBS Poll: Bush Ratings Continue Slide "Evaluatio...
- Susan Sontag on the Abu Ghraib images: "For a lo...
- MoveOn.org is launching a campaign to pressure Rum...
- How Fascism Starts Molly Ivins writes: "Normally...
- Another Bush-bashing book blockbuster, this one fr...
- Bush Blues How much worse can it get? How long ca...
- Video Shows Iraq Wedding Celebration: "A videota...
- AlterNet: Top 10 Conspiracy Theories of 2003-2004:...
- AlterNet: Victims Turning Perpetrators: "The war...
- Time For A Veto, Methinks The author G. K. Cheste...
- Give the people the truth: Michael Moore Wins Cann...
- One Woman Against The Bush Machine If you don't k...
- What Bush & Co. Really Want The Bush administrati...
- AlterNet: Is Bush the Anti-Buddha?: "When George...
- AlterNet: When Bonesmen Fight: "I hope some jour...
- Associated Press says Fewer Iraqis Working on Reco...
- World Gone Mad ABC News reports that "Israel's Ar...
- Sovereign necessity: "The US is now claiming tha...
- Bush Faces Death Penalty Under US War Crimes Law ...
- Phony Disengagement, Secret Escalation: "While t...
- Naomi Klein says the guards taking the rap for Abu...
- The Kansas City Star says: "The Bush administrat...
- Powell Versus Rumsfeld? CIA insiders are calling ...
- MSNBC - The Roots of Torture: "Toward the end of 2...
- MSNBC - The Roots of Torture: "By 2004, the United...
- MSNBC - The Roots of Torture: "With the legal gr...
- Newsweek - The Roots of Torture: "Gonzales concl...
- NEWSWEEK- The Roots of Torture: "By Jan. 25, 200...
- Newsweek - The Roots of Torture: "Originally, Ge...
- "The Fish Rots From The Head Down" Michael Moore'...
- You know there is something seriously wrong with y...
- OK Let's Be Constructive For A Change George Monb...
- Long Live Gandhi! When creating this blog, I chos...
- Better to Be Children - by Charley Reese: "We wo...
- The Ideal Solution The Washington Post says Iraq ...
- Attention! Attention! The Supreme Leader, in his...
- CounterPunch: "'When the containers were finally...
- Where Was Press When First Iraq Prison Allegations...
- Powell Muzzled By Press Aide An aide to Sec. of S...
- Surreal As if to prove that the modern-day USA is...
- O, Say Can You See...? So what has happened to th...
- Danish medics saw Iraqis tortured to death : "Dan...
- Sic Transit Gloria Rumsfeld The New Yorker today ...
- Iraqi In Custody Tortured To Death: "Spiegel TV ha...
- New Iraqi Gov't Can't Expel U.S. Troops: "The ne...
- SMH's Margo Kingston says "Oils ain't just oils, ...
- Powell Versus Bush? It looks like Colin Powell ma...
- A Military Intelligence Officer says: "The MPs and...
- Blame Bush Fred Kaplan looks at two stories which...
- Greenpeace Versus The Toxic Texan "Greenpeace, ch...
- 82 percent of Iraqis oppose U.S. occupation: "Fo...
- Wolfowitz Gets Whacked "Interrogation techniques ...
- How The USA Became A Nazi Fascist Cabal: Part 1 I...
- Terrorism: The Antidote Like Bush and his crazy n...
- The Guardian asks How can America get out of Iraq?...
- Ted Rall: "Torture Apologists" "If American life ...
- The America I Know... Bush claims the abuse of pr...
- Bush ratings in free-fall President Bush's overal...
- 'They abused me and stole my dignity': "An Iraqi...
- New Zealand News - - Secret US jails hold 10,000: ...
- Did Right-Wind Nuts Cause The Death Of Nick Berg? ...
- As Juan Cole says: "I don't care what Sufouk tol...
- Shame! Australian Government Not Protecting Austra...
-
▼
May
(146)
No comments:
Post a Comment