I came here today because I believe that American democracy is in grave danger. It is no longer possible to ignore the strangeness of our public discourse . I know that I am not the only one who feels that something has gone basically and badly wrong in the way America's fabled "marketplace of ideas" now functions.
How many of you, I wonder, have heard a friend or a family member in the last few years remark that it's almost as if America has entered "an alternate universe"?
I thought maybe it was an aberration when three-quarters of Americans said they believed that Saddam Hussein was responsible for attacking us on September 11, 2001. But more than four years later, between a third and a half still believe Saddam was personally responsible for planning and supporting the attack.
At first I thought the exhaustive, non-stop coverage of the O.J. trial was just an unfortunate excess that marked an unwelcome departure from the normal good sense and judgment of our television news media. But now we know that it was merely an early example of a new pattern of serial obsessions that periodically take over the airwaves for weeks at a time.
Are we still routinely torturing helpless prisoners, and if so, does it feel right that we as American citizens are not outraged by the practice? And does it feel right to have no ongoing discussion of whether or not this abhorrent, medieval behavior is being carried out in the name of the American people? If the gap between rich and poor is widening steadily and economic stress is mounting for low-income families, why do we seem increasingly apathetic and lethargic in our role as citizens?
On the eve of the nation's decision to invade Iraq, our longest serving senator, Robert Byrd of West Virginia, stood on the Senate floor asked: "Why is this chamber empty? Why are these halls silent?"
The decision that was then being considered by the Senate with virtually no meaningful debate turned out to be a fateful one. A few days ago, the former head of the National Security Agency, Retired Lt. General William Odom, said, "The invasion of Iraq, I believe, will turn out to be the greatest strategic disaster in U.S. history."
But whether you agree with his assessment or not, Senator Byrd's question is like the others that I have just posed here: he was saying, in effect, this is strange, isn't it? Aren't we supposed to have full and vigorous debates about questions as important as the choice between war and peace?
Those of us who have served in the Senate and watched it change over time, could volunteer an answer to Senator Byrd's two questions: the Senate was silent on the eve of war because Senators don't feel that what they say on the floor of the Senate really matters that much any more. And the chamber was empty because the Senators were somewhere else: they were in fundraisers collecting money from special interests in order to buy 30-second TVcommercials for their next re-election campaign.
In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, there was - at least for a short time - a quality of vividness and clarity of focus in our public discourse that reminded some Americans - including some journalists - that vividness and clarity used to be more common in the way we talk with one another about the problems and choices that we face. But then, like a passing summer storm, the moment faded...
The present executive branch has made it a practice to try and control and intimidate news organizations: from PBS to CBS to Newsweek. They placed a former male escort in the White House press pool to pose as a reporter - and then called upon him to give the president a hand at crucial moments. They paid actors to make make phony video press releases and paid cash to some reporters who were willing to take it in return for positive stories. And every day they unleash squadrons of digital brownshirts to harass and hector any journalist who is critical of the President.
For these and other reasons, The US Press was recently found in a comprehensive international study to be only the 27th freest press in the world. And that too seems strange to me...
Our democracy has been hallowed out. The opinions of the voters are, in effect, purchased, just as demand for new products is artificially created. Decades ago Walter Lippman wrote, "the manufacture of consent...was supposed to have died out with the appearance of democracy...but it has not died out. It has, in fact, improved enormously in technique...under the impact of propaganda, it is no longer plausible to believe in the original dogma of democracy."
Like you, I recoil at Lippman's cynical dismissal of America's gift to human history. But in order to reclaim our birthright, we Americans must resolve to repair the systemic decay of the public forum and create new ways to engage in a genuine and not manipulative conversation about our future. Americans in both parties should insist on the re-establishment of respect for the Rule of Reason.
October 06, 2005
TPMCafe has the full transcript of Al Gore's speech on the Threat to American Democracy:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Pages
Blog Archive
-
▼
2005
(1244)
-
▼
October
(173)
- As John Maxwell suggests, it's about time that the...
- Arianna Huffington: Ultimately, as Rich writes, th...
- Looking Beyond FitzgeraldSo Libby has been indicte...
- For anyone still confused about it, this WaPo piec...
- George W. Bush: The Search For Truth It's about t...
- What Next?Watching the detectives... This is a cri...
- Libby Indicted, Others Facing Sterner Charges?So m...
- The Real Reason For The Miers WithdrawalMiers - Go...
- It's Rove and LibbyFor now... Raw Story says Rove ...
- In Case You Missed It: Bush, Cheney And The CIAThe...
- Bush: A Headless Chicken?In the corrupted currents...
- Over To You, George...Mike Moore puts Bush on the ...
- Former Powell Aide Slams "Cheney-Rumsfeld Cabal"To...
- Schwarzenegger snubs Bush. Take that, bitch!
- Heckuva Job, Browneye Remember, that's Bush's man...
- Even the Washington Times is now saying Bush's Al ...
- The Most Important Criminal Case in American Histo...
- Roy Carroll: the truth shall set you free.
- Bush Hypocrisy Exposed (The NYT is doing nobody a...
- The Knives Are Out... ! Rove stabs Libby in the b...
- PlameGate: BUSH KNEW AND BUSH LIED!Today's big sto...
- Not Our Land, Not Our War Kristina M. Gronquist s...
- A Spanish High Court judge issued international ar...
- PlameGate: The MotivationCheney's long-time "War" ...
- PlameGate: Rumours, Speculation, Leaks, MusingsFle...
- After dancing in circles for days, Judith Miller f...
- PlameGate: Will We Ever Know The Truth?NYT examine...
- The War On MalignancyWhen will it end? What's the ...
- Will US Elections Be Stolen Again In 2006 and 2008...
- In the UK, a senior judge has said that the Blair ...
- BushWorld: How Have The Mighty FallenSorry, I can'...
- Attytood looks at another brewing scandal involvin...
- Is Hannah Talking? So has Ari Fleischer flipped, ...
- Commercialisation Of PoliticsFrom Think Progress: ...
- BushWorld Sucks Doug Soderstrom: Now that I am we...
- Iraq War Is The Real Crime Michael Moore: But the...
- US War AtrocitiesSMH: US soldiers in Afghanistan b...
- How Dick Cheney blocked Iran-Contra.
- How many years do you think YOU could stand, kissi...
- Flipping For DickJudy's testimony: It came in Augu...
- Miller's inaccurate info may offer Libby a loophol...
- WHIG Lies: Circumstantial Evidence From Frank Ric...
- Iraq's WMDs: The Pinch and Judy ShowJoshua Marshal...
- Dick's hole.
- Iraq's New Consitution On Hold From the BBC: The ...
- A United Nations official has called on Switzerlan...
- Benyam Mohammed al-Habashi One victim's story: O...
- Ted Rall looks to the future: do we laugh or cry?
- Heartless, Gutless Democrats Jonathan Schell, aut...
- Line 'Em Up, PatNow this is what the Internet is s...
- War: What Is It Good For?And now for some good new...
- Peace At Last In Iraq? Don't Believe The HypeFrom ...
- PlameGate: Miller's StoryPut on your reading glass...
- PlameGate: The Condi Connection Here's what Condi...
- Negroponte's Al-Zawahri Letter A FakeIt seems more...
- Harold Pinter Blasts Iraq WarPerhaps the best thin...
- Juan Cole Knows A Fake When He Sees OneJuan Cole h...
- It Was 40 Years Ago Today... John Pilger: In 1965...
- When and if Al Quaeda ever does strike again withi...
- What's Going On?If you ever wondered what the Iraq...
- Arianna predicts that the Judith Miller fiasco cou...
- Total Crap Why do liberal/left newspapers always ...
- Mr Two-Percent (Or Less?) From Think Progress: A ...
- Sniffing For DickJust in from Raw StoryTwo officia...
- The Miami Herald headline says it all: Is the Bush...
- Germany's Chancellor Schroeder bows out with a swi...
- Are Our Leaders Terrorizing Us? More often than no...
- Bush Co. Plans Military State Ted Rall and I have...
- It's LEDEEN!!!
- New York Times says Judith Miller is now free to t...
- Lest we forget: Even psychotic murderers have feel...
- Rice In Kabul We are - BOOM! - making - BOOM! - g...
- Judy Goes Fishing With PatJudith Miller probably t...
- Reading Between The Lines Norman Solomon re-phras...
- You Know Little George Is In BIG Trouble When... ...
- Americans Favor Bush's Impeachment If He Lied abou...
- Remembering The Dream That Was America Molly Ivin...
- Something to be aware of: US control of the Intern...
- David Corn looks at Rove's shifting PlameGate defe...
- Dowd On MiersGiven that the Bush White House has n...
- Ooooh... JUICY! With WHIG Too!!AMERICAblog quotes ...
- Nice to see something besides Iraqi car-bombs goin...
- The Nature Of The BeastDavid Ignatius on How the R...
- Who Would Jesus Kill?Via The Smirking Chimp: Jesus...
- Miller Must Testify (Again) to Grand Jury on Wedne...
- Dust off the Nuremberg Files: The Nuremberg Trial ...
- Iraq Lies: Follow The Money... Down The Hole Via ...
- A New And Better Way Doctor Robert's positive app...
- Innerestink SpeckoolashunsIn the wake of the Hurri...
- Iraq WMD Lies: The Real Questions As the blogging...
- Lot's of "I told you so"s on Iraq coming in these ...
- Is anyone in the USA ever going to acknowledge tha...
- One million await aid in quake-hit Pakistan.
- With indictments expected anytime soon in the Plam...
- What Has Bush Got To Hide? When Kitty Kelley brou...
- First it was WMDs, then Al Quaeda links, then it w...
- We Are All Dying In Iraq Cindy Sheehan's fascinat...
- Welcome To The Matrix, Neo Jason Miller tells his...
- Bush Family Business From The St. Petersburg Time...
- Praise be to Jay-zus! Freedom is on the march in A...
-
▼
October
(173)
No comments:
Post a Comment