THE BUSH administration's plan to bring democracy to the Middle East is now in ruins. In a nation where political responsibility still counted for something, the architects of that strategy would be forced to resign.Copyright 2006 Los Angeles Times
Remember the argument for the Iraq war — that the overthrow of Saddam Hussein would lead to a stable, democratic Iraq and bring peace between Israelis and Palestinians? Remember the argument that the key problem in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was lack of Palestinian democracy? Remember Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice's promise that the U.S. would "support the new Lebanon"?
In truth, reliance on democratization was always not so much a strategy as an excuse for the lack of one. It provided a flimsy cover for the Bush administration's inability or unwillingness to address the key challenges and opportunities of the region. These failures included walking away from the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and refusing to consider deals with Iran and Syria when, in the wake of 9/11, these regimes were extremely eager for compromise. As investigative reporter Seymour Hersh and Mideast scholar Flynt Leverett, among others, have argued, Bush forfeited the chance to recruit these two states as allies in the fight against Al Qaeda and the Sunni extremist world, which the Syrian and Iranian regimes have their own good reasons to hate.
Instead, the administration, backed by most of the Democratic leadership, has supported the Israeli government in its plan for a unilateral solution that would confine the Palestinians to Bantustans. It has treated Iran and Syria with unremitting hostility, trying to undermine the Syrian economy and impose sanctions on Iran, demanding concessions while openly proclaiming its desire to overthrow both states.
Not surprisingly, when the flare-up of fighting between Israel and the Palestinians provided an opportunity, Tehran and Damascus unleashed Hezbollah. This is an extremely risky and irresponsible strategy for Syria and Iran, but no serious student of the Middle East can claim that it is an unexpected one, given the situation in which the United States has placed them.
Far from promoting democracy in the region, the U.S. is being led closer to Israel's traditional three-part strategy toward its neighbors: reliance on deals with dictatorial regimes that fear their own people; promotion of divisions between different religious and ethnic groups; and, when necessary, war.
In Lebanon, Israel is justified in demanding that the Lebanese government exert more control over Hezbollah. But Israel must remember that Shiites represent more than 40% of the Lebanese population — and the vast majority support Hezbollah. Thus, the only way that Hezbollah can be controlled without massive violence is by integrating its members into the Lebanese state.
Crushing Hezbollah, by contrast, would require a military dictatorship of the Lebanese Christians and another horrendous Lebanese civil war with many thousands of deaths. Israel might be morally justified in promoting such a "solution" if Hezbollah represented a real threat to Israel's existence.
But Israel wants to pound the Lebanese state into cracking down on Hezbollah no matter the cost to the Lebanese population or to the hopes of a democratic future that Bush praised so highly only three months ago.
Elsewhere in the Middle East, the failure of the Saudi, Jordanian and other regimes to speak out on behalf of the Lebanese has nothing to do with democracy. It results from two factors: their fear of the expansion of Iranian and Shiite influence, and their fear of militancy in their own states. In any of these countries, democracy would lead to very different policies, ones much more hostile to Israel and the U.S.
The neoconservatives who shaped Bush's "strategy" toward the Middle East always embodied a quite Orwellian contradiction. On the one hand, they professed to believe that early democracy is possible for the Middle East and that it would solve the region's problems, including the Israeli-Arab dispute. On the other hand, many made no secret of their belief that, as neocon scholar Michael Ledeen has written (quoting Machiavelli), "it is better to be feared than loved." Raphael Patai, whose book "The Arab Mind" influenced neoconservative thinking, argues that Arabs chiefly respond to the language of force.
But as the experience of Israel shows, rejecting compromise and relying mainly on force leads only to endless conflict. Now that the U.S. dream of combining democratization of the region with submission to Washington's policies is dead, the U.S. too is faced with a stark choice: seek genuine compromise with key regional actors, or be prepared to fight repeated wars.
July 24, 2006
Bush's Middle East Democracy Flop:
Pages
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(2154)
-
▼
July
(164)
- So Much For Closing It Down...Halliburton builds a...
- Australian "Red Cards" And US War CrimesVia Juan C...
- Bush Neocons Want War With SyriaNasty stuff, via J...
- Where's GandhiSorry for not posting much lately, I...
- Karl Rove's Ultimate Wedge PoliticsThe BBC reports...
- Defying the SupremesLatest plans are still not goo...
- The Bright Side Of LifeAn attempt at optimism from...
- On The Up-SideFrom Scotsman.com/a>:Having said tha...
- On The Up-SideFrom Scotsman.com/a>:Having said tha...
- End Of EmpireOK, who is going to tell me that this...
- Ojala Que Si, Pero NoRobert Fisk dares to ask: Is ...
- Where Do You Go To, My Lovely?Methinks this is Con...
- Rice flies in for ASEAN security talks: With the f...
- Condi Goes To BeirutAnalysis from Informed Comment...
- Max Hastings says the west's moral erosion has und...
- Bush Silence On Pakistan ReactorEvery para f this ...
- American Chronicle says Bush's signing statements ...
- Reality Media: The GameYOUR ASSIGNMENT: You are a ...
- Desperate Bush Goes Begging For Votes And MoneyI G...
- Supreme Court Gets More WorkImagine a top Republic...
- Opportunity KnocksStrange to watch a right-wing UK...
- Bush Blows Another $96 Billion To Save His Sorry A...
- Interesting...Chavez forges ties with Belarus Mr C...
- Do You Know Where We're Heading?Lincoln Country Ro...
- At The Next Australian ElectionBoth major parties ...
- Laura Rozen was right... Iran activist 'snubs Whit...
- How Do You Know When The World Is Truly, Deeply FU...
- Follow the Money, Follow the LogicSo Bush's USA gi...
- Hold Them Accountable: A Tool For The Net"Pop-Up P...
- From Laura at War and Piece:The top Italian police...
- Bush's Middle East Democracy Flop: THE BUSH admini...
- Sources: Negroponte Blocks CIA Analysis of Iraq “C...
- If We Killed Them, They Must Be GuiltyAlan Dershow...
- The Hardest WordCenk Uygurposts an apology from a ...
- Black George W. Bush
- Israel's MotivationsIt's now pretty clear that ass...
- The last 9/11 detainee goes free without charges: ...
- Smells Like More Failed DiplomacyBush's USA blocke...
- Comments?From where I stand today, the end of the ...
- Suicide? My Arse!MP Norman Baker, a Liberal Democr...
- Suicide? My Arse!MP Norman Baker, a Liberal Democr...
- Democracy? My Arse!Bush's democracy project backfi...
- The worst part is: as of last Thursday, we're stil...
- MUST READ: Cheney and Rumsfeld Not Telling Bush Re...
- U.S. Speeds Up Bomb Delivery for the IsraelisA hug...
- Heckuva Job, BoltonWhite House moves to confirm Jo...
- Should Be Interesting...Laura Rozen reveals that s...
- Gorby Goes To OzGorbachev: "The current violence i...
- The West Abandons Lebanon To Its FateIt is becomin...
- Meanwhile, Back In DCDan Froomkin asks: Cover-Up E...
- The Massacre Of Marwaheen Robert Fisk has more det...
- US Jews Call On Bush To Stop Israeli ViolenceAn on...
- The View From Tel AvivSMH reports Little interest ...
- US Media Remains In Thrall To Bush RegimeThe lesso...
- The Jewish Thing: Muddying The WatersJust as the P...
- PlameGate And Worse: When Will The Penny Drop?Good...
- Bush's USA: The View From AfarThis report from Al ...
- Comments Here If Ya Got Em...
- The History Of Our Times... is already being written.
- Bush's ME: Coming Home To RoostCharles A. Kupchan'...
- Doing Nothing, Achieving NothingKRT Wire: In a dep...
- Yo, Mista Bush!Am I the only one who suspects Bush...
- Kicking And ScreamingThe new plan for Guantanamo t...
- A good URL to bookmark: Journalist Express: News a...
- At least someone in the US media still does journa...
- MUST READ: Australia's Pro-Zionist LobbyTranscript...
- What a strange war... This from CNN: Israeli warpl...
- It Was 70 Years Ago TodayFrom Crikey: A poll for S...
- Sleeping Bush And The Seven DwarfsFrom today's NYT...
- Animal House SummitBy MAUREEN DOWD, NYT Op-Ed Colu...
- Robert Fisk's Paradise Lost: In the year 551, the...
- Padilla Was Framed For Not Co-operatingAntiwar.com...
- Hey, I am getting hits from Georgetown Uni (where ...
- I Blame The Government!Conservative Anger Grows Ov...
- Hey George!Killing these Lebanese (and Canadian, a...
- Is Al Gore The Only True Leader Left In The USA?Bo...
- ... And Damned StatisticsBush's Poll Numbers Are R...
- Wired World Versus... Wierd world: Australia's lea...
- Gunmen Kidnap 600 in Washington, D.C.From Robert H...
- Put Your Comments Here
- A "Sleeper" Story Set To ExplodeAttorney General A...
- MahmoudiyaIraqi Forces Stood By During Massacre: I...
- So What Happened To All That 2004 Tsunami Money?Wa...
- "Expert" In NYT: No Danger Of Regional WarBe not a...
- What Does Coulter Have To Do To Get Arrested?Becau...
- Bush PigI spend hours a day reading the news, but ...
- US PsyOps? Or Greedy, Immoral Opportunists?You rea...
- George Bush's Australia: A Nuclear Power?John Howa...
- Iraq Death Rate AcceleratingThe latest UN report s...
- Clowns Rule: The Wingnut White HouseTony Snow tell...
- Bush Says SHIT Live On CNNOf course, Bush is alway...
- An editorial from Beirut's English-Language "Daily...
- Civilians Pay The PriceMore from Robert Fisk: The...
- Cindy Sheehan, Hugo and George: On a recent appear...
- Neo-con War II: Unfolding While We WatchAny articl...
- Israel = Too Hard BasketDaily Kos Kops Out: Me? I ...
- How Much Was The Bribe This Time?Iraq and Australi...
- Meanwhile, back in Mexico: With hundreds of thous...
- Shock! Press Tells It Like It Is!Bravo to Michael ...
- Who Is Backing Ghorbanifar?Yep, he's ba-a-a-ack: A...
-
▼
July
(164)