Denial Still RulesSimon Jenkins in the
Guardian :
The frantic scrabbling for an exit strategy from Iraq now consuming Washington and London has passed all bounds of irony. Help from Syria and Iran? Surely these were the monsters that George Bush and Tony Blair were going to crush, back in 2003? Surely the purpose of the Iraq adventure was to topple these terrorism-sponsoring, women-suppressing, militia-funding fundamentalists in favour of stability, prosperity and western democracy? ...
As we approach the beginning of the end in Iraq there will be much throat-clearing and breast-beating before reality replaces denial. For the moment, denial still rules. In America last week I was shocked at how unaware even anti-war Americans are (like many Britons) of the depth of the predicament in Iraq. They compare it with Vietnam or the Balkans - but it is not the same. It is total anarchy. All sentences beginning, "What we should now do in Iraq ... " are devoid of meaning. We are in no position to do anything. We have no potency; that is the definition of anarchy...
To talk of a collapse into civil war if "we leave" Iraq is to completely misread the chaos into which that country has descended under our rule. It implies a model of order wholly absent on the ground. Foreign soldiers can stay in their bases, but they will no more "prevent civil war" than they can "import democracy". They are relevant only as target practice for insurgents and recruiting sergeants for al-Qaida. The occupation of Iraq has passed from brutality to mere idiocy...
If London and Washington really want help in this part of the world they must start from diplomatic ground zero. They will have to stop the holier-than-thou name-calling and the pretence that they hold any cards. They will have to realise that this war has lost them all leverage in the region. They can insult and sanction and threaten. But there is nothing left for them to "do" but leave.
Via
AL.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(2154)
-
▼
November
(178)
- FINALLY SOMEBODY GETS IT!!! WHOO HOOO!!! YEEE HAAH...
- Me, I Never Liked PoodlesFrom The Times: In a deva...
- Bush says Maliki is my kind of guy. Mind you, he s...
- Impeachment Day Is Coming...Go visit afterdownings...
- Oh, Good Grief!Michael Ledeen gets top billing on ...
- Baker's got nothing: The bipartisan Iraq Study Gr...
- Gandhi Versus HowardOK, folks, time to announce ye...
- Al-Maliki's Catch 22Bush's long-awaited summit wit...
- Taking It To The StreetIranian President Mahmoud A...
- Bush the dickhead: Webb, a decorated former Marine...
- Change Gonna Come: New BlogAs we move into the pos...
- Phase One Of The Withdrawal?Pentagon Considers Mov...
- Jimmy Carter just called the Iraq War "one of the ...
- The Case For ImpeachmentWorkingForChange-Tomgram: ...
- IRAQ + US = FUBARIt seems events on the ground are...
- Michael Moore calls for an immediate withdrawal: 1...
- Bush-bashing is popular! Keith Olbermann, Talkin' ...
- Murdoch's Gotcha “And to think that Murdoch was on...
- Spotlight on Cheney: Hail to the chief. The man wo...
- AWB: Yet Another Shameful Day In Australian Histor...
- Does Anybody Out There Even Care?War Protestor's P...
- Why Do They Hate US?What's worse? The fact that th...
- Everybody hates Israel.
- Tom Engelhardt asks Will Papa Bush's Old Pals Prol...
- Time For Panic?The shit is definitely hitting the ...
- Picking It Up A StepLaura Bush calls Bob Woodward ...
- UN Ambassador Knew Iraq War Details In Early 2002T...
- Novak: The latest Evans-Novak Political Report sug...
- The Chaser's War on TerrorCourtesy of Antony Loewe...
- Worst Golf Shot In HistoryTotally off topic, but s...
- Who Will Stop Murdoch?Richard Branson: "All of us ...
- US Working On Diplomatic Exit StrategyTom Hayden a...
- How Bush's Friends Manipulated Oil Prices For The ...
- Coincidence? Election over, gas prices up againFro...
- War Is Always WrongWaPo's Richard Cohen: "In a pos...
- US OUT NOW!A new poll from World Public Opinion sh...
- The World Feels Popppy's PainGeorge H.W. Bush in A...
- We Fight Them Because They Fight UsBlair again: "T...
- MUST READ MUST READ MUST READ 'War on terror' coul...
- Wierd Scenes Inside The FOX GoldminePanic hits New...
- For anyone with broadband, a global news source wo...
- Lessons from the Vietnam WarI sure wish Bush would...
- Wierd Little StoryCrew faulted in crash of plane d...
- Bush in Indonesia: He noted that it wasn’t the fir...
- The Worst Place In The WorldA new survey says Bush...
- Will Durst: People always liked Bush because he se...
- Blair in Afghanistan: Here on this extraordinary p...
- Ron Suskind: The president understands more about ...
- Sing A Song
- Did the CIA kill Bobby Kennedy?Today would have be...
- The Ultimate Indignity: They Couldn't Even Get Sad...
- Bloggers V. Status Quo: The Spin Is Spun OutThis i...
- So Is An Iran Attack Now Off The Table?A big part ...
- "Consider helping out your favorite bloggers..."Sa...
- Monday Run-DownJuan Cole at Informed Comment focus...
- Antiwar.com is appealing for funds to stay afloat:...
- Gandhi's Plan For Peace In IraqHere are five concr...
- Conduct UnbecomingThe Progressive Daily Beacon say...
- Go, Go, Go!Ted Rall wants action from the Democrat...
- The Dis-United State OF AustraliaPeter Hartcher sa...
- By The WayLet me take a moment to recommend some e...
- Bush's Last, Desperate Roll Of The DiceAs Australi...
- Bush's Iraq: Double Or NothingBush is a self-cente...
- Denial Still RulesSimon Jenkins in the Guardian : ...
- YOU GO GIRL!They write letters: As an American who...
- Who Controls The US Government?Sibel Edmonds goes ...
- Speaking Faith To PowerWhat a strange thing for Ge...
- Beyond The Pail14.11.06: Steve Bell.
- Bush Authorized Torture, GulagsThose of us with lo...
- Why Alexander "Baby Face" Downer Is Such A GeniusD...
- Fox News Gave Terrorists In Iraq $2 Million!From W...
- MUST READ: The Carlyle White HouseAn excellent and...
- Another controversial Bush renomination: Three con...
- The Bush Study GroupBush Initiates Iraq Policy Rev...
- Hiding The Inconvenient FactsGreens are sueing the...
- Bush 41 Blames ‘Bloggers’ for ‘Ugly’ Political Cli...
- Big Brother Is Your FriendAddressing the rich and ...
- Now HERE Is Something To FearAccording to an artic...
- The USA's Strange CultFor Evangelicals, Supporting...
- In Case You Missed ItA look at the previous (abort...
- ReliefYeah, things are different. I feel like I am...
- I Have A DreamThat one day Bush will choke on his ...
- Antony Loewenstein has a great quote from Democrat...
- Isolated: Victims Of The InsaneAn isolated Tony Bl...
- Bush once defined his job as "catapulting the prop...
- WHOO HOO! Dems To Chase AWB BribesUS Democrats to ...
- There's a rat in the kitchen: Lieberman Leaves GOP...
- Cakes Walk, Frogs MarchA wierdly interesting artic...
- Bush's PoodlesToday Bush is meeting the Iraq Study...
- Big thanks from Michael Moore: Friends,You did it!...
- What a strange thing for Bush to say: "One freedom...
- Does Cheney Still Rule?Mike Whitney thinks it's a ...
- Say A Little PrayerFor Molly Ivins, who is battli...
- Bush's USA: A Destabilizing Influence in Latin Ame...
- You Can Do AnythingFor anyone who ever doubted the...
- Grrr, Bloody Democrats...The Gulf News says Democr...
- Exit Strategy: Peace In The Middle EastMolly Ivins...
- Too Late For "The Long Peace"?Tom Engelhardt on Bu...
- Aren't You Glad You Didn't Move to Canada?
- Howard: Stranded Like A Shag On A RockAustralian P...